Category Archives: Political witterings

The burd’s views on the hot potatoes of the day/week/month

Fringe Firsts

There are so many good things on at the Edinburgh Festivals this year loosely and not so loosely themed around the Referendum.

I’m not sure I’m one of them.

But if you ever wanted to hear me witter in person and not just on here…

All Back to Bowie’s is David Greig’s brilliant idea and is a wondrous gallimaufry of opinion, chat, poetry, music and polemic. It has a stellar line up appearing every day in the Yurt in St Andrew’s Square from 12 noon to 1pm.

Tomorrow I’ll be the one Unwashed and more than Slightly Dazed, on a discussion panel about campaigning with Stephen Noon and Brian Cox.  Yes, THE Brian Cox.  Which means I might be speechless, for once.  Also appearing are the wonderful Cora Bissett, Kirstin Innes, Sam Small and David Greig himself.  No, I’m not sure how I got invited either…

And I’m also appearing in Suffragette City on 20 August.  Talking about wimmin in the referendum, no doubt.  I’ll be the one being the *total blam-blam*.

Not content with this little lot, I’m also taking part in the Scottish Parliament’s Festival of Politics on Saturday 15 August in the session on Political Strategy chaired by Henry McLeish, former First Minister and Labour MSP, from 1.30 to 3pm.  I’ll mainly be talking about the engagement of young adults in this referendum campaign, linking to the book wot I wrote, but also no doubt, straying into all things gendered too.  Every year, the Festival of Politics develops and there are always so many great sessions and events, some of them free. This year, it has an amazing line-up of pointy heids worth listening to (I’m not one of them). Worth including in your Fest diary, for sure.

Talking of The Book, I’ll also be at Luath Press’s Referendum Fest which runs from 18 to 22 August at the Quaker Meeting House just off Johnston Terrace. My session is on Friday 22 August (just before the rather excellent Michael Keating and one-time bloggery pal Malcolm Harvey – if you fancied making an afternoon of it…).

Luath Press is one of Scotland’s foremost independent book publishers, giving space to proper authors and folk like me alike to get a range of perspectives and issues out there. They will also no doubt be at the Book Festival and some of their wares on sale in the Book Festival store – well worth a browse and a purchase or two.

And if you’d rather see and hear some real talent, try Alan Bissett’s the Pure, the Dead and the Brilliant at the Assembly Rooms; National Collective at the Storytelling Centre; Bella Caledonia and Scottish PEN on 20 August at the Saltire Society with an afternoon of events on the theme of A Public Press; either or both versions of 3000 Trees; or David Hayman in the Pitiless Storm, also at the Assembly Rooms.

I’ve been to the first and it was indeed, pure dead brilliant. Am hoping to catch some of the rest – maybe see some of you there, or even at one of mine, before I retreat back to the doorsteps for the last, big heave to independence.





The future is coming on

I know it sounds ridiculous, but I’ve written a book.  And it’s going to be published soon, apparently, by the lovely Luath press as part of Gerry Hassan‘s Open Scotland series.  Or maybe they’ll pulp it, which would probably do us all a favour.

Titter all ye like; it won’t match my own embarrassed guffawing about it.

In the book wot I wrote about Scotland’s 20-somethings, I wanted to use the lyrics from Gorillaz’ seminal* noughties track, Clint Eastwood, as chapter headings but this is a big no-no – copyright fees for such borrowing are eye-watering.  So sue me now for doing it here, Messrs Albarn, Hewlett and Jones:  I have nothing you’d want anyway.

I should probably explain why this song’s lyrics struck a chord while collating data and information for *The Book*.  In fact, it didn’t take long for it to play on a loop in my head during the project, which was a tad annoying, given that I’d spent much of the preceding ten years removing it as an earworm.

The Big Yin was ten when Clint Eastwood was released, but it stayed in his most-played tracks throughout adolescence.  Its use in films, in sampling and covers throughout the decade ensured its longevity, as did each year of pre-pubescent and pubescent children awakening afresh to its potency.  It’s taken me until now to get it.  It’s not the technology nor the concept that has given it legs, but the lyrics, and especially the chorus.

And what has this pleasing meander got to do with anything?

On Friday, in what is now Gordon Brewer’s Big Debate on Radio Scotland, I was rounded upon for suggesting that younger generations were probably going to vote yes.  On cue, up popped two possibly-planted No-voting 19 year olds to dispel my theory, which Harry Donaldson of the GMB seized upon.  Never mind the polls – for once, apparently – here’s the evidence in front of us.  All two of them.

And for all there’s been much chatter about how this referendum campaign has enervated Scotland’s youth, much of it has focused on 16 and 17 year olds who will vote for the first time ever in September.  No one has had much to say about those aged 18 to 29 and their voting intentions.  Partly that’s the pollsters’ fault, because they have been all over the place in mapping this demographic’s voting intentions.  They have used different age definitions at various points and the weighting of poll samples of 18 to 24s and 25 to 34s can create such margins of error as to make findings meaningless.  Nor is there much evidence of a trend, of a forward march relentlessly towards one outcome or the other, so there have been few talking points.  Indeed, such is the volatility of their voting intentions, that far from being the Independence Generation, they are more like the Mebbes Aye Mebbes Naw one.

But that has changed a little in the last three months.  These tables take poll data from ICM, TNS-BMRB and Survation, the only companies to have surveyed in each of May, June and July:



ICM May - July polls





TNS BMRB May - July polls





Survation May - July polls





There’s no easy way of presenting disaggregated data – or at least, I’m not useful enough technically to do so.  But these three polls all suggest that to varying degrees, there is a softening of the no vote, a shift to yes and a rise in the number of don’t knows. Indeed, among 25 to 34s who are much more likely to vote than 18 to 24s, ICM and TNS-BMRB even have Yes as winning in most months.

I’ve included the 35 to 44s to show that here too, there is movement, though all pollsters suggest more of a roller coaster ride in voting intentions.

Effectively, the polls suggest that these voters are the key age demographic for the Yes campaign:  the closer we get to Referendum Day, the more the gap is closing between No and Yes and might even be opening up in some ages between Yes and No.  Moreover, there are still plenty of their votes to be won, with consistently more than a quarter saying they have yet to make up their minds.

These age groups are clearly the furrow to plough for Yes in the remaining forty days of the campaign. Yes needs to nail the myth and the fear that free university tuition would be threatened by independence.  It needs to get childcare back on the agenda, ignore those spouting millions and billions to talk it down and win the argument that free childcare is good for children, good for families and good for the economy (and isn’t on offer within the UK). It needs to emphasise how these young adults are the hardest hit by Westminster, especially if they are in work, and how key changes in tax and earnings policy in independent Scotland will benefit them in particular.  And it needs to do the vision thing, offering up independence as their one chance, their one opportunity at a better future.

This recent polling data suggests that younger adult voters in Scotland actually get this last, fundamental argument in the independence case.  The new poster campaign with its focus on “one opportunity” suggests Yes gets it too (though mixing the messaging dilutes its impact, as does the stark, male styling).

And this analysis suggests three things:  such a high level of undecideds among three key age groups means there is all to play for and that this referendum is not over yet;  given their lower propensity to actually vote, getting them out to vote on Referendum day is a challenge requiring precision planning;  Yes needs to win over as many of the undecideds as it can in all three age groups, to counter the much higher number of No voters in the over 55s in particular, who are also much more likely to vote.

While it might all come down to differential turnout on the day, there’s a message to be taken to the nation’s Grannies in particular.  Vote no because you think things are fine as they are, because at your time of life, you can’t be bothered with the change and you’d rather have the “devil you know” and you could well be consigning your grandchildren to a future they neither want nor have voted for.

That’s a stark and hard message for Yes to get across but it must find a way to hit home that those with the least to gain from independence could thwart the aspirations of those who will benefit the most.  20 and 30 somethings could help by initiating the inter-generational conversation: a wee blast of Clint Eastwood and especially, the chorus would be a good place to start:

I ain’t happy, I’m feeling glad
I got sunshine in a bag
I’m useless but not for long
The future is coming on


*seminal means making the Rolling Stone’s top 100 of the decade – it’s in there at 38.  My blog, my rules.

Women for Independence National Day of Action

WfI voter reg day

All around Scotland today, Women for Independence will be reaching out to other women – particularly those whom traditional politics has found easy to ignore.  Our aim is simple.  To encourage more of them to register to vote in Scotland’s referendum on 18 September.

There are women, especially in marginalised communities, who have never voted.  Never seen the point.  Politics is something done to them, in which they feel they have little stake or little chance to influence things.  But when the referendum is explained, that it is not a vote for a party or a politician, but a vote for themselves, their families, their future and Scotland’s future, they get it.  And tend to sign up.

And while Women for Independence’s key aim is to encourage more women to vote Yes in the referendum, the grassroots movement for women, by women is also about enabling more women to participate in the debate, to make their voice heard.  The simplest and most obvious way of doing that is by voting on 18 September.

With just under a month to go until voter registration closes, it’s vital that more women are reached.  Today, local Women for Independence groups will be out in cities, towns and communities all over Scotland – why not pop along and give them a hand.

Find out what’s on in your area at the website and the Facebook page



Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 6,734 other followers

%d bloggers like this: